Best Eyeliners for Watery Eyes

Best Eyeliners for Watery Eyes – Long-Lasting & Water Proof

Finding a suitable eyeliner for your watery eyes with long-lasting capability is almost as difficult as drawing a perfect wing in one go! Either the liner is too dry or too thin to stay on your watery eyes. Your eyes can get a lot worse if the eyeliner you are wearing is not specified for watery and sensitive eyes. So you have to look wisely for the best eyeliners for watery eyes if you want to save yourself from the pain.

If your eyes becomes watery whenever you wear eyeliner or some other eye makeup, that means the product you are wearing isn’t suitable for your eyes. This is why it is a must to use hypoallergenic products that are not harmful for watery eyes.

Before you proceed further, we recommend you to take a look at How to Apply Eyeliner on Waterline and Brightening, Drugstore, Nude & White Eyeliners for Waterline

Here’s a list of some best eyeliners for watery eyes down below. Check them out and find the perfect eyeliner for your watery eyes.

Comparison Table of Best Eyeliners for Watery Eyes

Stila - Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner for Sensitive & Watery Eyes

Rimmel Scandal’Eyes - Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil

Revlon – Color Stay Eyeliner Pencil

Waterproof liquid eyeliner

Stays in place

Smooth and pointy tip

Dries quickly and lasts long

Waterproof gel eyeliner pencil

Lasts from day to night

Creamy and smudge-free formula

Suitable for sensitive & watery eyes

Contains long wearing technology

Rich and intense color

Built-in smudger and sharpener

Available in variety of shades

Check Price
Check Price
Check Price

Maybelline Eye Studio - Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner

Sephora Collection - Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner

Jillian Dempsey - Natural Kôhl Eyeline

Soft and creamy gel formula

Highly pigmented color

Long lasting & waterproof gel eyeliner

Oil-free and smudge-proof

Long-lasting & waterproof eyeliner

Built-in smudge tip & sharpener

Retractable waterproof eyeliner

Creamy texture and budge-resistant

Luxurious long-lasting eye pencil

Ultra-pigmented & smooth formula

With built-in blender tool

Organic and natural ingredients

Check Price
Check Price
Check Price


1. Stila – Stay All Day – Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner for Sensitive & Watery Eyes

Stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner for Sensitive & Watery EyesStila’s Stay All Day Liquid Eye Liner is one of their best selling eyeliner. Just like its name, it does stay all day, giving you the perfect bold and dramatic look. The smooth waterproof, and smudge-free formula glides swiftly, causing no irritation, so it’s safe to say that this eyeliner works best for sensitive or watery eyes.


  • Easily applicable for everyone.
  • Super pigmented and thin.


  • It has a shiny finish.


2. Rimmel Scandal’Eyes – Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil – BlackRimmel Scandal’Eyes - Waterproof Gel Eye Liner Pencil

Rimmel Scandal’Eyes Gel Eyeliner Pencil gives you the best fashion-forward look with a dramatic effect. The highly intense color helps you create the most edgy look and stays put on your eyes all day long. It’s waterproof, and the smudge-free formula glides smoothly and causes no harm to your watery or sensitive eyes even if you wear a contact lens.


  • Causes no irritation to eyes.
  • Highly pigmented color.


  • Control the sharpening with a traditional sharpener. 


3. Revlon – Color Stay Eyeliner Pencil – BlackRevlon - Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil

Revlon Color Stay Eyeliner Pencil is America’s #1 best long-wear eyeliner. It’s creamy and intense color formula lasts up to 16 hours. You can use the pencil to create the perfect line but if you want a softer smoky look, then use the built-in smudger. This eyeliner is tested to be non-irritating, making it suitable for watery eyes and people who wear contact lenses.


  • Comes with a smudger and pull-out sharpener.
  • Ophthalmologist tested.


  • Smears when rubbed.


4. Maybelline New York Makeup – Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner – Blackest Black

Maybelline - Eyestudio - Lasting Drama Gel Eye LinerMaybelline Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner is here to give your eyes a dramatic effect for a lasting impression. The soft and creamy gel eyeliner is effortless to use with the applicator that comes with it. The smooth texture sways entirely on your lids, and the intense pigment defines your eyes thoroughly. The oil-free and smudge-proof formula is ophthalmologist, dermatologist, and allergy tested, which makes it the best eyeliner for watery or sensitive eyes.


  • Available in amazing different colors
  • Best for both heavy and natural look.


  • A bit hard to take off.


5. Sephora Collection – Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner – Matte Black

Sephora Collection - Retractable Waterproof EyelinerSephora Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner is not only waterproof but also lasts pretty well. Apply the creamy texture of eyeliner along your lash line and gain the best results without the fear of getting watery eyes. You can use the built-in smudge tip to create a different look. Also, if the tip feels a little blunt, sharpen it with the pull out sharpener.


  • Single stroke is enough to get that dark and clean line.
  • Will not make your eyes red and puffy.


  • Might get dry if the cap is not fitted.


6. Jillian Dempsey – Natural Kôhl Eyeliner – Cruelty-Free Waterproof Pencil with Built-in Smudger

Jillian Dempsey - Natural Kôhl EyelineJillian Dempsey Natural Kôhl Eyeliner contains all the organic and naturally-derived ingredients hand-selected by Jillian Dempsey herself to create the best waterproof eyeliner. Since most of the ingredients are organic, there is no chance of getting chafed or watery eyes, so rest assured. The richly pigmented color makes your eyes pop, or you can get a smokier look by using the built-in blender tool.


  • Cruelty-free product.
  • Contains Jojoba oil, organic shea butter and marula oil for rich color pay-off.


  • Easily smudgeable.

Frequently Asked Questions [FAQ]


  • What are the best eyeliners for watery eyes?
  • Stila’s Stay All Day Liquid EyeLiner.
  • Jillian Dempsey Natural Kôhl Eyeliner.
  • Revlon Color stay Eyeliner Pencil.
  • Maybelline Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner.


  • Why do eyes water when you wear eyeliner?
  • The makeup can wash into the eye and clog the Meibomian glands, making eyes more dry and more likely to tear up .


  • What can cause watery eyes?
  • Lots of things can cause watery eyes, like infections, allergies, injuries and even aging.


Wearing an eyeliner while having watery eyes can be really annoying because the product keeps coming off, and in no time, you’ll end up with raccoon eyes. So the eyeliner you use must be super waterproof, smudge-free, certified for sensitive eyes, and stays for a long time, or else you will have to deal with the struggle of having waterfalls from your eyes.

Beauty, Fashion, Makeup Hacks, Makeup Tutorial

Products You May Like

Articles You May Like

Best Flat Iron for Natural Hair | Hair Straighteners

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *